Board Thread:Versus Battles/@comment-26615071-20170611001705/@comment-29853277-20170615123104

Roy's:

Intelligence: High. Better than Roy

Experience: 15 years old, but I'm not sure when he started fighting. I'll tentatively say he has less experience than Carl Range: A lot less than Roy's Superhuman Physical Characteristics - on par. Roy has faster combat and reaction speeds though, but slower movement speed.

Fire Manipulation,  Attack Nullification with his sword (Fire based attacks only),  Can increase the power of his fire with Affinity  - cool, extra damage. Carl doesn't use fire, so the nulling bit is irrelevant. Flame burst is also probably more likely to screw him over than let him kill Carl though.

Can absorb blunt hits and use it with his affinity to increase his strength - Carl's standard equipment isn't listed, so I'll assume he uses his fists in melee, in which case Roy can absorb the blunt hits.

Skilled at using a sword - Nice. Martial arts probably even that out a bit, but IRL a skilled sword user is going to beat a skilled martial art user.

Rage Power - so he can boost his power a bit. Even's out Carl's berserk mode.

Carl's:

Intelligence: High. Better than Roy

Experience: 25 years old, but I'm not sure when he started fighting.

Range: A lot higher than Roy's.

Superhuman Physical Characteristics - on par. Faster movement speed, but slightly slower reactions and combat speed.

Enhanced Senses - mildly helpful

Martial Arts - combined with his age he is likely the superior fighter

Photokinesis (Type 1) - all of type one? Gives him some advantages with blinding. Burning could probably be absorbed unless it is specifically fire Roy absorbs

Angelic Energy Manipulation - Does it do anything in particular? Or is it just the type of magic energy he uses?

Tactile Telekinesis - requires contact. Don't know the extent (can he rip someone into small pieces the instant he touches them?)

Longevity - maybe he'll outlive Roy

Regeneration (High-Low) - regrowing limbs is always nice.

Shapeshifting (Complete change of appearance) - if they are in NYC as SBA says, it could let him hide in the crowd.

Wing Manifestation and manipulation - I mean... yay? I don't know if the ability to sprout wings and hit people with them really qualifies as a power... But sure, it gives him more ways to attack.

Magic (Type 2) - Doesn't really tell me what he can do with it, unless he can do everything the page lists.

Berserk Mode - doesn't make him strong enough to reach the next tier, but it gives him a strength buff, while also likely removing his high intelligence

Energy Armor Generation - yay, armour. Don't know what it does, so I'll just assume its a slight buff to dura

Omnilingualism - Ahh, here is the real hax. This is clearly the ability that will give him the win. Probably a one-shot. Makes it a stomp honestly. Ought to be restricted.

All up, it seems to me Carl holds a strong advantage, so I'll vote for him.