Thread:Aeyu/@comment-24503208-20180114024843/@comment-30299084-20180114041843

Honestly, the entire tiering system is based on logical structure, even if it contains things that are illogical or are stated to surpass logic. The entirety of that second supposition is facilitated by a suspension of disbelief in the viewer's mind.

As far as making "logical sense," of 1-A, it's actually pretty easy.

Something that is beyond dimensional complexity, whether that be spatial dimensions, temporal dimensions, or any other arbitrary dimension created. It doesn't necessarily mean that by definition those things are metaphysical. They could still possess physical attributes to some degree that could be measured, and whatever their higher structure might be could be rationalized through logic as well.

Also, the Genetic Fallacy doesn't really apply here. We're talking about a tiering system created by individuals to logically determine powerscaling. =Genetic Fallacy= 

(also known as: fallacy of origins, fallacy of virtue) Description: Basing the truth claim of an argument on the origin of its claims or premises.

Logical Form:

The origin of the claim is presented.

Therefore, the claim is true/false.

This is not the place to be bringing such a complaint up. But I'll address your concerns, if you're supposing that this is what I'm doing. You are actually committing this fallacy, as you are stating that because characters who are beyond dimensional limitations are said to be formless and abstract on the Tiering System page, that that is the truth and that anything aspatial and atemporal is abstract and illogical because that's what you deduced it to mean.

I'm gonna bust out a hard truth right now. The tiering system is not perfect. It is unscientific in a number of ways, but represents a system which has been molded to fit arguments about powerscaling in a way that can at least marginally be agreed upon. The truth of the matter is that in science, math and philosophy, there do exist concepts and examples of things both atemporal and aspatial. What the tiering system page says is honestly irrelevant to the MAIN definition:

"Characters that have no dimensional limitations".